Restaurants

Water Witch Restaurant

4.6 96 reviews Closed 123 Town Cir, Pouch Cove, NL A0A 3L0, Canada

Discover this place

Water Witch Restaurant in Pouch Cove is a culinary gem that captures the warmth of Newfoundland hospitality. This quaint, primarily take-out eatery emphasizes fresh, high-quality seafood, with many patrons praising their divine cod. One customer raved about the homemade batter, noting its delicate lightness compared to typical beer batter, setting a new standard for fried fish. Another highlighted the ice cream appetizer, which boasts a delightful thickness, making it a unique start to a fulfilling meal.

The owner’s dedication to customer satisfaction shines through her willingness to accommodate diners despite primarily serving takeout. Reviewers frequently mention the generous portions and delightful service, with Janet, the heart of the restaurant, being a beloved figure among locals and visitors alike. Whether you are stopping for a quick lunch or savoring a relaxed meal with loved ones, Water Witch promises a comforting experience. With a menu featuring everything from succulent chicken to tempting burgers, it's evident this eatery has something for everyone. You'll not only leave with a content stomach but also with fond memories of genuine hospitality and hearty food. A must-visit for anyone seeking a taste of local culinary excellence!

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner

Atmosphere

Casual

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Water Witch Restaurant before visiting.

Reviews for Water Witch Restaurant

4.6

96 reviews

100%

15%

Review highlights

Based on 96 reviews

Water Witch Restaurant is widely praised for its exceptional hospitality and welcoming atmosphere, often going beyond expectations to accommodate guests. Customers frequently highlight the freshness and quality of the fish dishes, particularly the cod, which is considered a standout offering. The restaurant's generous portions and thoughtfully prepared meals contribute to its strong appeal. Despite primarily being a takeout venue, patrons appreciate the flexibility to dine in when possible. The warm, friendly service and local charm make it a beloved spot, especially valued by both locals and visitors seeking authentic Newfoundland hospitality. Overall, Water Witch Restaurant is regarded as a hidden gem with consistently delicious food and a personable dining experience.

M Savoie

Oct 18, 2025

Stopped for lunch. It is a take out mostly but the owner/cook accomodated us to sit a a table. The cod was divine. Really really good fish.

G J

Oct 07, 2025

Talk about real hospitality, ordered way past closing. Filled the order and let us eat inside despite this being a take out. The cod was so fresh, by far the best I've ever had and I spend a lot of time fishing and cooking myself! Fish platter with an extra piece is what had. Ice cream for appetizer which was also real thick creamy soft serve. Well worthy of a tour in itself for some fantastic fresh fish very lightly battered. Not a thick standard beer batter, home made starter sauce home made vinegar home made recipes, just fantastic.

S P

Sep 09, 2025

Such a delicious place! We’re fairly new to the area for work, and I think we’ve eaten here almost every week (sometimes multiple times, haha). All of the food is fantastic and the service couldn’t be any better! Janet is so kind and an absolute riot. You gotta check out this hidden gem!

ash

Sep 07, 2025

Went their with my girlfriend, the lady is so sweet she guided us to nearby spots to look at and was the sweetest old lady ever, I hope she is always happy and the the food omg it was so good and the portions were so big we loved it def going back soon

Jane Jackson

Aug 31, 2025

We were just touring and needed a bite of lunch. This was the only place on the map in Pouch Cove. Just as we walked in the skies opened up. The very kind lady offered to let us sit in the other room instead of eating in the car. This was the Newfoundland hospitality that we’ve heard about. It was just a hotdog and a grilled cheese sandwich, with coffee, but the hospitality made them the best we’ve had. If I return I will be back for the fish!! And thanks for letting us share the table to the construction guys who were eating there too!

Andy Z

Aug 14, 2025

The restaurant is named after the schooner Waterwitch which ran aground nearby and whose crew was rescued by the local fishermen. The place is take out only and serves various deep-fried goodies. I personally really enjoyed the cod bites but I'd ask for extra dressing as the food was on the blander side. A pro move is to picnic at the nearby William Tuff Lookout.

Greg West

Aug 09, 2025

Visited the Water Witch Take Out for the first time. I ordered the seafood platter. Three large scallops, 5 shrimp , one large piece of cod fish & a mountain of fries. Great prices . Absolutely delicious and a great deal of $15 + tax. I highly recommend eating there if you're in the area or better yet , just take a drive out to visit the area. Greg West St.John's

Lisa Glynn

Jul 25, 2025

We just tried the fish from Water Witch and wow. We are from Calgary, Alberta and sadly don't get fish like this out there. She was so wonderful to pan fry it for us as deep frying is not good for either of us. We truly enjoyed our dinner as we watched the boats sail and the gulls flew. Wonderful experience all round. Ross and Lisa Hunter